Sermon Study · Sermon Notes
locsermonstudy.com/participant/2026-10-21-lgbtq/notes/
LGBTQ+
October 21, 2026 · Sean McDowell
A small-group study of a message at Living Oaks Church, Thousand Oaks. Free and open to anyone.
- Big Idea: God designed sex and marriage for our good, and we are set free only when we know his design and live it out, with love and kindness toward a broken world.
Opening
- Conrad Wozniak recalled last week's talk, Greg Koukl on the problem of evil, and prayed from 2 Timothy 3:16: all Scripture is breathed out by God.
- Question cards were on the tables, and a handful would be read after the talk.
- He quoted Carl Trueman: the sexual revolution "has turned the moral world upside down." In Acts the apostles were accused of turning the world upside down, but Jesus was turning it right side up.
- He introduced Sean McDowell: professor of apologetics at Talbot School of Theology, Biola University; two master's degrees, in philosophy and theology, and a PhD in apologetics and worldview studies; author, editor or co-author of more than 20 books; on the teaching team at his church in Southern California; and co-host of the Think Biblically podcast.
01
Back at This Church
- Sean last spoke in this sanctuary in 2018, at the conversation and debate with Matthew Vines. At least half the room had been there.
- He credited Jon Noyes, who had the vision for that event "when a lot of people, let's just say, did not think it was a good idea."
- Same topic, "very different circumstances."
- His plan: a few stories on how the conversation has shifted, then the big questions, then the Bible texts, then questions from the room.
02
Three Stories: How the Conversation Shifted
- About 2003–2004: Sean was a new high school Bible teacher at a private school in south Orange County.
- A sophomore said an atheist in an online chat room had shattered his faith. Sean had him write down every objection, and for months they worked through the list, one at a time. Then the student stopped coming and said he was fine.
- Two years later, at the school retreat that opened the year, Sean found the student, now a senior, sobbing. He said he had hoped Sean could not answer his objections, because he was gay: "if I die, I'll go to hell. And I can't keep living because my life is a living hell."
- Sean put his arm around him: I love you, I'm here for you, this doesn't change anything, let's work through it together.
- God used it to soften Sean's heart toward the LGBTQ community. If this kid's life was a living hell, how many others in churches and communities felt the same? Coming out of the culture war of the 80s and 90s, the church needed to lead with grace and kindness. This was 11 years before the Obergefell ruling in 2015.
- 2014: Matthew Vines wrote God and the Gay Christian, and a lecture of his had gone viral with well over a million views. He became the public face of the claim that you can be gay and a Christian.
- His Reformation Project held a conference in Washington, D.C., to reform the church from within to accept same-sex marriage. Sean went with Alan Shlemon, next week's speaker, not to protest but to listen "under the radar."
- It felt evangelical: coffee and donuts, announcements, worship, a beautiful church. For three days there were 60 to 90 minute lectures. The arguments were sophisticated, and Sean was not sure he could answer them all, so he and Alan went and did the research.
- In a small-group exercise, the brochure on the table read "You are welcome here." Sean told the group he held a very different view and asked if that applied to him. They said yes.
- In 2014 this was still a voice from outside the church.
- 2023: At a conference at Andy Stanley's church in Atlanta, Stanley held up a same-sex couple as a model of faithfully following Jesus. Sean rarely names names, but "This one pushed me over the edge."
- Stanley says he is not affirming. Sean's answer: "you're functionally affirming."
- Sean got sick, so Alan went, and they reviewed it in depth. The conversation is now inside the church.
03
Why We Can't Move On
- Many people are "understandably tired of this conversation" and want to move on. In many ways Sean does too.
- We can't, "because the Bible is clear about God's design for sexuality," and staying faithful to Scripture is what it takes to really love people.
- So keep being gracious, loving and kind, and stay fully committed to the authority of Scripture. Sean: "the question at play here is a question of biblical authority."
- After two decades of study, he said the newest book from two prominent scholars recycled old arguments. "There is no way to get to affirming same-sex sexual relationships and affirm the authority of the Bible, period."
- Don't take his word for it: study it for yourself.
04 · 1 Corinthians 6:9–10
Why Not Agree to Disagree?
- Christians can disagree on the death penalty, women in pastoral roles and the age of the earth, and remain brothers and sisters in Christ.
- Why not put same-sex marriage in that category? In 1 Corinthians 6, Paul places those who practice same-sex sexual behavior among those who will not inherit the kingdom of God. The list opens and closes with that warning, "to make sure we don't miss it."
- It is not one category of people. The list includes idolaters, the sexually immoral, thieves, the greedy and drunkards. "All of us should read this and have serious pause" and repent.
- Critics who point to how many evangelicals look at pornography are, Sean said, "not wrong about that."
- There is a difference between saying "God, I messed up," and saying this behavior is part of my identity and God approves of it.
- Paul never places sexual sin among the debatable matters, such as the day of worship or the food we eat.
- If we love our neighbors, we have to speak the truth, "because it's the truth that brings freedom."
- Is homosexuality the worst sin?: At a conference around 2018 or 2019, a student asked Sean that, word for word. Most questions have a question beneath the question.
- Outside, the student, 17 or 19, told Sean he had same-sex attraction. He had told no one. He cried and hugged Sean for about three minutes. He knew his parents loved him, but he had heard them make homophobic comments.
- His real question: "Will you accept me? Will you love me? Do I belong?" Sean: "That's the heart cry that all of us are asking."
- Many raised in Christian homes share their same-sex attraction or gender confusion, feel rejected, and then find a community that says "you're perfect as you are."
- We cannot compromise what Scripture says, even when it offends, because it is the truth and it gives freedom. But above all is the call to love. As Paul says, without love "We have nothing."
05 · Genesis 1:1
Is There a Designer?
- As abortion turns on what the unborn is, sexuality turns on one root question: "is there a God who has designed us to function a certain way?"
- If there is a maker of our bodies, of marriage and of sex, "we're actually only free if we follow the designs and plans of the maker." If not, and everything came from a purposeless material process, there is no way we are supposed to live.
- A smartphone is not a waffle maker, a parachute or a basketball. Only when you know what it is for and use it that way are you set free with it. The same is true with God.
- The Bible begins, "In the beginning, God created." Before we learn that God is holy, righteous or merciful, we learn that he is creator. Purpose is built into the world: we discover it; we don't create it.
- A teacher can assign homework but not a student's sex; that is discovered. The phrase "assigned at birth" treats sex and gender like Play-Doh instead of gravity. Ignore gravity and there are consequences. The same is true of God's design.
06 · Genesis 1:27; Genesis 2:23–24
What the Bible Says
- Genesis 1:27: Made in God's image, male and female both have value and dignity. Maleness and femaleness are built into the world by God, who then commands people to multiply and fill the earth.
- Genesis 2:23–24: The woman is like Adam, human, and different from Adam, female. A man leaves his father and mother, not two fathers: from the beginning the pattern is one man and one woman, a man and his wife, one flesh.
- One flesh: every other bodily function a person can perform alone, but for procreation each of us has half a system. Only a man and a woman can form that union.
- To those who say this is the Old Testament: it is rooted in creation, not in the law of Moses.
- Matthew 19:3–5: Jesus was asked about divorce, not same-sex marriage. That Jesus didn't address something does not make it okay; he didn't address incest either. Until about 50 years ago there was no debate in the church about what marriage is.
- Jesus answered, "haven't you read?" He quoted Genesis 1 and Genesis 2, pointing back to God's original design as the standard.
- Genesis 2 alone answered the question about divorce. By adding Genesis 1, male and female, Jesus showed that "marriage is a sexed institution."
- What's at stake: Three or four years ago, in a YouTube conversation with a progressive Christian, Sean was asked what is at stake if he is wrong. His answer:
- Marriage is "the primary illustration God uses to teach his love for the church." Unfaithfulness to God is called spiritual adultery, and Ephesians 5 makes marriage a signpost of God's love for the church. Reinterpreting marriage damages that picture.
- Remove sexual difference and there is no reason to limit marriage to two. The 2015 ruling described marriage as two people who love each other, but love does not make or break whether something is a marriage.
- If love and commitment can override what Paul says about same-sex behavior, why wouldn't they make an incestuous relationship okay?
- Since COVID, books, podcasts and characters in movies have pushed toward polyamory, where everyone in the group is partnered with everyone else, unlike polygamy, one man with several wives. Sean has read articles about a new book on a theology of polyamory, though not the whole book: it makes "the same arguments" made for same-sex marriage for 15 to 20 years.
- Romans 1:26–27: "For this reason" sends us back to what comes before.
- "Disgraceful passions": the problem is not how strong the passion is but its direction.
- The women did likewise what the men did, and the men left natural relations with women for men. So the passage is about same-sex sexual behavior.
- What does "natural" mean? Start with the context, not a dictionary. Verse 18: people suppress the truth. Verse 20: God's invisible attributes are clearly seen in creation. Verse 23: images of birds, animals and reptiles echo the Genesis creation account. Paul's backdrop is the same as Jesus': God's original design.
- Some say Paul meant pederasty, men using boys. But Greek had several words for that and Paul uses none of them, and there was no female version, yet the women did the same thing as the men.
- Summary: Quoting Greg Koukl, marriage is "One man and one woman who become one flesh for one lifetime." All sexual behavior outside that violates God's design.
- The consequences are showing up in the culture. A child told that two dads equal a mom and a dad can feel that longing for a mom betrays the dads who love him.
07
Where We Go From Here
- Stay faithful to Scripture: know it, read it, study it. Sean reads it almost every morning. The Scriptures are God-breathed, and people flourish only when they live as the creator made them.
- When someone says you are on the wrong side of history: "if your savior has risen from the grave in the middle of history, you will always be on the right side of history."
- We need boldness and clarity, and "absolute, unmitigated grace and kindness" for our neighbors. The reputation of evangelicals has fallen on hard times, but people who know us by our love find us much harder to dismiss.
- Get outside your comfort zone. Make friends with people who see the world differently. Talk to them. Pray for them.
- Ask yourself: when people around you are broken economically, physically or emotionally, is their next thought to find a Christian who will love them without judging? And will you come to mind?
- Jesus came in grace and in truth. We need bold truth, commitment to Scripture, and a love for our neighbors "that can only be explained supernaturally."
Questions and Answers
- Conrad Wozniak introduced Sean and moderated. Some questions were his own; others came from cards at the tables.
- How do we as Christians engage in relationships with people who don't think like us? (Conrad)
- Sean: it is part of a bigger question, how to care for people who see the world differently. Christians often stay in Christian circles, out of insecurity or busyness. But Jesus was a friend of sinners, and sinners wanted to be near him. Is that true of the people who see us?
- On a book tour around 2014, a woman complained that her kids saw "filth" at Disneyland on Gay Day. Sean said he would find out when Gay Day was and take his kids, to meet people made in the image of God. If your child says something offensive, "teach your kids how to apologize."
- His father, Josh McDowell, now 87, always modeled meeting people on their own turf, without a legalistic bone in his body.
- Listen. Love people the way you would want to be loved. "Don't have a secret agenda."
- Sean is writing a book with an atheist who calls himself a New York media elite. He grew up in Greenwich Village, said 40 percent of the men he knew growing up were gay, and had never met an evangelical naturally. He watches Sean because Sean lets people talk, which shows confidence.
- How can you love someone but not affirm their beliefs, and not destroy the relationship? (audience cards)
- Sean: each of us leans toward being a grace giver or a truth teller, a lawyer toward truth and a counselor toward grace. We need both.
- If you are not living in that tension, either you are not engaging people who see the world differently, or you lean too far one way. You can't have too much grace, unless it starts compromising truth.
- Pray and get counsel. You can tell someone: I'm a Bible believer, I don't know how to navigate this, I want to love you and stay in relationship with you.
- His principle: "I want to be as gracious as I can be without compromise in scripture or my conscience before the Lord."
- Conrad added Caleb Kaltenbach's picture of a rubber band: stretched out, it holds the tension between grace and truth, and we live in the middle.
- After the three-minute hug, what did you tell the young man, and how can we show up for students? (Conrad)
- Sean: what he said before mattered more. He had shown the student: I see you, I care for you, I'm not threatened or offended, God loves you and so do I.
- Afterward he asked how the student would tell his parents. The student wrote back that he couldn't. Sean offered that he and his wife would drive up and sit with the student and his parents. It turned out not to be needed.
- Why: the parents would hear it all at once, and another person in the room makes them less likely to say something they regret.
- He told the student to give his parents grace: this is new to them, and parents think about things kids don't, like grandchildren. The student told them eventually; Sean has not been in touch for years.
- What is the "plus" in LGBTQ+, and what is coming next? (audience card)
- Sean: lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender; Q for questioning or queer; I for intersex; A for asexual. The plus is every sexual minority identity other than straight and cisgender, where gender identity matches biological sex.
- Next: polyamory will become more accepted and respectable, though not what everybody does.
- Pornography and artificial intelligence are changing everything. The internet made pornography everywhere in the 90s, and Sean said it is "no coincidence" that the shift toward same-sex marriage followed. AI will speed this up.
- Conrad connected this to Romans 1.
- Good news: the number of students who identify as LGBTQ has dropped. Among Gen Z it has "dropped off significantly," though Sean said "I'd have to double check" the numbers. Studies on Gen Alpha are due in 6 to 12 months.
- Sean reads much of the rise as a trend. Some young people have gender dysphoria from their earliest years that the internet, schools or friends cannot explain, but they are the minority.
- If we are invited to a same-sex wedding, how would you counsel us? (Conrad)
- Sean: many of his friends see this differently. First, thank them. Being invited to what is probably the most special day of their life means you are close, and he wishes more Christians were invited. Family, with an invitation you are obliged to accept, is a separate question.
- He would not go. Two people of the same sex cannot marry; the state can call it marriage. Frank Beckwith: "you can eat an ashtray, but that doesn't make it food."
- A wedding is "a public celebration of a union." He cannot celebrate one that violates God's design and is not good for the couple.
- Thank the person, lean in relationally, and decline in love. That refusal shows how deeply you believe this and how much you care for the person.
- Hard case: if his wife wanted to go, he would have to love and listen to her. Get counsel, be prayerful, and make the decision that is right before God.
Resources
- Conrad asked Sean about the books and materials he brought.
- End the Stalemate: How to Move Past Cancel Culture to Meaningful Conversations, written with Tim Muehlhoff. Greg Koukl and Tim Muehlhoff are two of the people who have most shaped how Sean does apologetics.
- Chasing Love, written for students: God's design for sex, marriage and singleness first, then hard topics like homosexuality, living together, divorce and transgender.
- Replicas from Manuscript Shop on Egyptian papyrus, including P66, John 1:1 and 1:14, from about AD 200. It answers the claim that the idea of Jesus as God was invented at the Council of Nicaea in 325. Sean gets none of the proceeds; they support next-generation apologetics. Papyrus bookmarks were free.
- Sean was flying to Florida the next day to speak for Cru, so he could not take deep personal questions that night, and pointed people to the church staff.
Final Word
- Conrad asked for one final word: how do we think biblically about this issue?
- Sean: God is the one who designed sex, and his design is for our good. "It's only when we know God's design and we live it out personally and relationally that we're set free."
- Do it with love, kindness and charity toward a broken world that desperately needs the gospel.
Next study: Islam, October 28, 2026 · locsermonstudy.com/participant/2026-10-28-islam/
Scripture quotations marked ESV are from the ESV Bible, © 2001 by Crossway. Text Edition: 2025. Used by permission. Permissions: crossway.org/permissions. Prepared for this small group from the October 21, 2026 message; questions and applications are editorial study material.
Sermon Study is an independent small-group resource based on sermons at Living Oaks Church. It is not the official church website.